2 Comments
Nov 4, 2023Liked by Bruce Ivar Gudmundsson

Concerning your first paragraph RE: Lifelong learning strategies:

My understanding of Hegel is that

Hegel would likely suggest a more dialectical approach to learning (but of course). This means that instead of starting with a rigid plan or simply exploring new topics randomly, learners should engage in a process of critical thinking and reflection. They should challenge their own assumptions, question the information they are presented with, and synthesize new ideas with their existing knowledge.

This approach to learning is reflected in Hegel's philosophy of history, which sees the world as developing through a process of conflict and resolution. Hegel argues that we can only understand the present by understanding its past, and that we can only create a better future by understanding the present.

Some textual quotes from Hegel that support this view of learning:

"The truth is the whole. But the whole is only the essence that completes itself through its own development." (Hegel, Science of Logic, p. 15)

"The dialectical method is a movement from the immediate to the mediated through the mediation itself to the immediate." (Hegel, Phenomenology of Spirit, p. 75)

"The process by which the Spirit comes to know itself is a dialectical process. It begins with an immediate knowledge of itself, but this knowledge is incomplete and inadequate. The Spirit then proceeds to negate this immediate knowledge and to seek a higher, more comprehensive knowledge of itself. This process of negation and synthesis continues until the Spirit finally arrives at a complete and adequate knowledge of itself." (Hegel, Lectures on the History of Philosophy, Vol. 3, p. 365)

In other words, Hegel believed that the best way to learn is to engage in a process of critical thinking and reflection, where we challenge our own assumptions, question the information we are presented with, and synthesize new ideas with our existing knowledge. This process of dialectical learning can help us to develop a deeper and more comprehensive understanding of the world around us.

Here is an example of how a student might apply Hegel's dialectical approach to learning a new topic, such as the American Civil War:

The student would begin by gathering information about the Civil War from a variety of sources, such as textbooks, primary documents, and historical accounts.

The student would then critically evaluate this information, challenging any assumptions or biases that they encounter.

The student would then synthesize the information they have gathered into a coherent understanding of the Civil War.

The student would then reflect on their understanding of the Civil War, considering its implications for the present and the future.

Through this process of dialectical learning, the student would develop a deeper and more comprehensive understanding of the American Civil War.

It's not to say that Hegel's approach is without setbacks and flaws, but it is interesting nonetheless. So yes, know when to fold 'em and when to put them to good use.

Expand full comment
Nov 6, 2023Liked by Bruce Ivar Gudmundsson

With finite time (and $$$ for books) we really do have to pick and choose what we study. There's no sense in reading a thousand-page tome for what can be surmised in a couple hours of lecture, especially when it will only really end up absorbed in the form of a few key points.

Expand full comment