With this essay, I begin a series of ‘discourses’ that build upon points made by Wallace Brett Donham in his Education for Responsible Living. As you might expect, both the title of this project and the approach that I take with the component essays owe much to the Discourses on the First Decade of Titius Livius of Niccolò Machiavelli.
‘I am disturbed by the failure of all types of collegiate institutions to prepare their graduates for the inevitable but unpredictable novelty of the problems they must face in life, or to take an understanding part in meeting the needs of our democracy.’
In the course of their confinement, people who complete conventional classes suffer much in the way of caprice. Thus, they eventually learn the art of tolerating the tiny tyrannies of teachers. However, in the course of accommodating pet peeves of pedagogues, school-bound students rarely encounter surprises of the sort that abound extra muros, the unprecedented problems created by the collision of forces, whether fetid or fresh, in motion in the outside world.
Indeed, rather than preparing people to thrive in the face of such surprises, the experience of conventional schooling repeatedly assures them that, whatever the task at hand, some authority has already assembled an array of suitable solutions. Alas, and, indeed, alack (hat tip to David Crowther), the very nature of antecedent answers, which were necessarily composed before the appearance of the problem in question, deprives them of their utility.
What is worse, the expectation of authoritative answers makes people vulnerable to scams of a certain sort, traps set by scoundrels who prey upon people raised on the praise, prizes, and perquisites lavished on those who color within the darkly printed lines.
Source
Wallace Brett Donham Education for Responsible Living (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1944)
Related Reading





