Recently, at a Family Dollar in the Mojave, I overheard a couple speaking German. Immediately, my mind sprang into action, composing sentences that might come in handy should the Cowboyliebende Touristen ask me for directions. I quickly realized, however, that, after forty-six Fraktur-filled years of reading the language of Goethe, Schiller, and Hohenlohe-Ingelfingen, I lacked two or three of the words I would need to help the two Truckstop fans locate the giant cactus they had traveled so far to see. And so, in my shame, I hid behind a large display of “unnecessary plastic objects” (hat tip to Nanci Griffith) until my not quite interlocutors left the store.
Later that day, for the sake of my other Substack, I worked my way through several French texts on the subject of Edwardian ironmongery. Once again, my amour propre dipped, like a Muppet in a ballroom dancing skit, each time I looked up a word that, fifty-eight years after learning the lyrics to Frère Jacques, I felt I should have known.
After several visits to the dictionary, I realized that, thanks to my innocence of forges and presses and such, I was as baffled by the English equivalents as I was by the French originals. This insight led me to another. Had I been able to give directions in German it would have done no one any good, because I had no idea where the giant cactus in question could be found. Finally, I reminded myself that, for much of my childhood, I had replaced “sonne le matine” with “somelematime,” which I imagined as a breakfast food akin to cream of wheat.
So, with these tales in mind, I offer the following observation.
A language is a big thing. The bigger it is, moreover, the more, and faster, it grows. Thus, when you decide to learn a new language, or, for that matter, to improve your command of your mother tongue, you commit yourself to a journey without end. To put things another way, there will always be texts that resist easy reading, songs you cannot grok, and useful phrases that fail to come to mind.
Languages like camouflage and harassment packages, ongoing and always changing to suit the situation. It would have been interesting if they were selling giant plastic cactus’ at the Dollar Store and everyone had to figure that one out!!